Generational changes facing family businesses

Natalie McR

Australia’s family businesses are in an era of transition as corporate rules change and younger generations forge their own paths.

McCullough Robertson corporate partner Natalie Kurdian says she is seeing many businesses reviewing their structures and facing challenging succession decisions.

Capital gains tax reform and the impending changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts was often the prompt for a major rethink of all aspects of family businesses, as well as wills and estate plans.

“But the smarter families aren’t rushing into anything,” she said.

“They’re doing the analysis now and keeping their options open – rather than rushing headfirst into a restructure or sale for the sake of a tax fix.”

Ms Kurdian said the changing expectations of younger family members were contributing to owners considering selling their businesses that might have previously passed from one generation to the next.

Younger generations were increasingly interested in establishing their own careers and businesses before considering a role in the family enterprise.

“We’ve seen that (younger) people tend to want to prove themselves first – to launch their own business, or do their own thing,” Ms Kurdian said.

“That venture may not be a permanent career, but it can still cover a significant period of time. And meanwhile, the founder of the family business is getting older, and they can’t wait for that next generation forever.”

Ms Kurdian said McR was seeing family business owners seeking advice on preparing businesses for sale when their children had established successful careers elsewhere. There are also many examples of some but not all children being involved in the family business along with the founder, but all children having equal ownership rights. That has its own challenges when it comes to major decision making such as selling or seeking investment from a third party.

She said these changing family dynamics highlighted the importance of governance and succession planning to protect family assets and relationships across a variety of circumstances.

“The key to a good succession planning is governance, education and design, and probably in that order,” she said.

“The real value is the conversation, it forces the solution to succession planning to come into consideration.”

Ms Kurdian said many successful family structures used a family constitution to establish shared values, decision-making arrangements, rules around family employment and processes for resolving disagreements.

Separate family councils and business boards or investment committees, with independent representation, could also help distinguish family relationships from commercial decisions and bring that independent judgment to important decision-making milestones.

She said, to protect multigenerational businesses, younger family members should be introduced to business decision-making early and be given opportunities to learn and develop financial skills.

“I think it’s really important to bring them onto committees early, give them some real but limited responsibility and have them invested in their own financial education,” she said.

Ms Kurdian said governance arrangements needed to evolve as businesses grew, particularly when family members developed different financial priorities or wanted to exit.

Poor documentation of loans, related party arrangements, informal promises and other family arrangements could create disputes and reduce the value of a business when prospective buyers conduct due diligence.

“I can’t begin to tell you how many times clients have assumed that everything has been documented, and then when they eventually need the underlying documents, they find out they don’t exist or, if they do exist, they discover that they have been making decisions in a manner that are contrary to the terms of the underlying documents.”

Ms Kurdian recalled a dispute involving family members who owned a company but lacked adequate mechanisms for resolving disagreements.

The conflict became so serious that the company’s ability to pay employees and suppliers was potentially threatened.

She said company directors needed to remember their responsibilities to the business, regardless of their family relationships.

Another major risk was succession planning that failed to distinguish between ownership and control of family assets.

A founder’s will, for example, did not necessarily determine what happened to assets held in a family trust, while an enduring power of attorney did not automatically allow someone to act as a company director.

Ms Kurdian recommended reviewing governance arrangements annually, as well as following major family or business events, including marriages, divorces, deaths, disputes and a liquidity event.

She urged families not to rush into restructuring arrangements purely to respond to the Federal Government’s planned tax changes.

The broader opportunity was to examine whether existing structures protected the family’s long-term interests and provided appropriate control and succession arrangements.

Partner content